The Pros and Cons of Modern Graniteware Roasters

What Is Graniteware Cookware Made Of?

Graniteware is just a type of enamelware and it is also a brand name.

Graniteware is also a widely-used term in the enamelware collectors’ community to refer to the enamelware items made from the 1870s until the end of World War II. The older graniteware pieces were made of tin or iron. They had more layers of glass coating and were heavier compared to modern kitchen items. Graniteware kitchenware gained popularity fast because of the convenience of the glass surface combined with the strength of the metal. The glossy porcelain surface was easier to maintain than heavy rust-prone cast iron pieces.

Graniteware kitchenware has nothing to do with Granite except its similarity in appearance. Today graniteware kitchen items are made with a steel core and glass coating. Porcelain enamel is fused with metal at 2,000 F creating a non-porous, inert, and naturally non-stick glass surface. The Graniteware items made today are thinner in construction and more lightweight than Grandma’s used to be. 

Is the Graniteware Made Today Safe for Cooking?

Modern Graniteware is made of thin carbon steel covered with a layer of porcelain enamel. The glass coating is inert and free of harmful chemicals. It will not interact with any type of food or change the taste or color of your meals. If the porcelain coating is not damaged, Graniteware cookware is safe for cooking and storing any type of food including highly acidic dishes. If there is a chip on the outside of the cookware, it will not affect the item’s safety or cooking ability, but if the coating is chipped off on the inside, you must stop using it for food preparation and storage.

Modern Graniteware Roasters

Columbian Home Prod. 0511-1 Covered Rectangle Roaster (Product from Amazon)

Today’s GraniteWare roasters are thinner and less sturdy compared to older models. Some cheaper models are thin and flimsy and may have sharp edges which are not finished safely. But most of those roasters are still good enough to cook your Thanksgiving turkey to perfection or for baking your own “artisan” bread. These pans are perfect for handling large meals and can be used for any type of food you can roast in an oven.

  • Inner carbon steel core distributes heat evenly and quickly.
  • The dark porcelain surface absorbs heat quickly, lowering cooking times.
  • The products are lightweight and much easier to handle than comparable cast-iron items.
  • You can cook meals in the oven without any mess.
  • The smooth glass surface allows for easy cleaning.
  • The food comes out tender and delicious.
  • Affordable prices make this cookware a reasonable choice for budget-minded customers.
  • This cookware cannot be used on glass surfaced stoves, as they can crack the cooktop.
  • Modern Graniteware is too thin to hold heat well.
  • Thin-layered GraniteWare is prone to chipping, especially if dropped.
  • Despite the manufacturers’ claim that the surface is non-stick, many users experience sticking issues. I often have burned food stuck to the bottom and sides of my granite roaster. However, the burnt residue will come off easily if you leave the pan in the sink to soak with some soapy water.
  • Some buyers find today’s Graniteware kitchenware too ordinary and unattractive. 

Cleaning and Care

The impervious surface makes this cookware easy to clean. Most GraniteWare roasters are dishwasher safe, per the manufacturer’s claims, but they also clean up easily by hand, using soap and water.

To remove the burnt juices, fill the pan with warm soapy water and let it sit for a few hours.

Make sure you are using gloves whilst washing to prevent cutting your fingers on sharp edges.

Do not heat the roaster while empty.

Do not drop it on hard surfaces to avoid chipping.

Store the cookware by turning lids upside down and placing it inside the roaster. When you store smaller roasters inside a larger one, place a dish towel between the lids and the pan to prevent chipping while being stored.

3 thoughts on “The Pros and Cons of Modern Graniteware Roasters”

  1. does graniteware really shatter glass top electric stoves? I just purchased a set and the salesman never mentioned that what do I do?


Leave a Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.


By continuing to use the site, you agree to the use of cookies. more information

The cookie settings on this website are set to "allow cookies" to give you the best browsing experience possible. If you continue to use this website without changing your cookie settings or you click "Accept" below then you are consenting to this.